I think this is is perfect. My brothers dog Maggie approves.
Next is a request from my nephew Wyatt, he wanted a stuffed German Shepherd dog. I found the pattern in the book "Knit Your Dog" I do not remember the author but this book has a lot of dogs in it this German Shepherd turned out great also.
He's very happy you with this creation. My son also wanted these finger puppets he rarely asks me do make him any thing so I could not refuse. He found the pattern on this page, http://krawka.blogspot.com.au/2015/01/its-bird-its-plane-no-its-finger.html?m=1
Here is a picture of my finished finger